You've got a lot of nerve
to say you've got a helping hand to lend
you just want to be on the side that's winning.
I know the reason
that you talk behind my back
I used to be among the crowd you're in with.
Bob Dylan 1965
When a professional sports team far exceeds expectations, invariably more people start to root for them. At that point, the long-time fans will often mockingly describe the new fans as fairweather fans. The implication is that they don't really deserve to root for the team; they don't really care about sports and are only pretending to like the new team because everyone else is doing it.
The truth is, however, that logically it really only makes sense to be a fairweather fan. First, a little background. Growing up in a mid-sized town, Louisville, I did not have any local NBA, NFL, or MLB teams. The only game in town was University of Louisville basketball and an occasional minor league baseball game. Like a lot of kids growing up in that situation, I started rooting for the first team I saw on TV that won a lot and was exciting. For me that was Magic’s Lakers and Staubach’s Cowboys. In baseball I liked the Cincinnati Reds, because they were the closest team to Louisville, and the local media adopted them as the hometown team.
As a close to obsessive sports fan, I followed these teams as closely and passionately as anyone would in a big city with their local team. Over time however, something changed. My love of sports did not. But as I grew up I began to find it harder and harder to root for teams or players that I didn’t like or couldn't play. I don't expect athletes to be role models. It's not that I think their character is worse than the average population; I think their character is the exact same as everyone else, and people put in their unique situation of too much money and too many beautiful young girls would act in the same way. It's just that when you can't stand someone it's hard to root for them.
So the first casualty was the Reds. This happened during the infamous Marge Schott era. Hopefully you don't remember her. I do. She owned the team in the 80’s and 90’s, and will most be remembered for her derogatory comments towards African-Americans and Jews, as well as her ownership of Nazi memorabilia. That ended my love of the Reds, and it never came back. As for the Cowboys? Look, I tried to keep rooting for them. I really did. But you just can't. The owner, Jerry Jones, is an egomaniac who ran the best coach in the NFL, Jimmy Johnson, out of town. This was because Johnson wouldn’t give Jones enough credit for the titles the Cowboys won. Their quarterback, Tony Romo, chokes in pressure situations at a more consistent rate than any player I've seen in my lifetime. The team has consistently brought in criminals and underachievers. They’re not good. Seriously, what's there to like?
The second reason that it makes no sense to blindly root for the same team year after year, is what if they suck? Sports is the only entertainment I know in which people feel obligated to spend their time and money on a product that is weak. If Tom Cruise is in five movies in a row that everyone tells me are great, and I like Tom Cruise, I'll go see his movies. But if all of a sudden every movie he's in is horrible, and he's in a new movie that a good friend of mine and RottenTomatoes.com tell me is more of the same garbage, why would I go see it? No one will ever criticize me for not supporting Tom Cruise. Why spend time and money on something that you know will be lame?
R.E.M. just announced that they're breaking up. In my mind they're one of the 10 best bands in rock history, maybe top five. I have every one of their albums from 1983 to 1992. It's been all downhill since, to the point where they haven't put out a good song in about a decade. I obviously don't spend any more time or money listening to their music. Yet I've never had anyone come up to me and say, “You know, I can't believe that you no longer support R.E.M. What kind of fan are you? What? You’ve been listening to Brandi Carlile? You’re just a fairweather Brandi Carlile fan. I was listening to her when she was in diapers. Before it was cool to like Brandi Carlile. You don't deserve to listen to her. You’re pathetic”.
Look, life's too short to waste time on anything, especially bad entertainment. Now I understand why someone who grows up in a city with a pro sports team would always root for them, and have a hard time cutting the cord. That team brings up happy memories and it's a bridge to your childhood. We're naturally loyal, and after spending so much time following a team you almost feel guilty letting go. Also, after a while it almost gets to be a habit. But you can't rationally argue it makes a ton of sense.
So at least for now, in football I've watched more Patriots games in the last few years than any other team. The reasons are simple. I think Tom Brady is the best football player I've seen in my lifetime, and I’ve spent way too much time watching football. They’re exciting. I like their coach, Bill Belichick, because I love how he handles the media and his offense is the most complex and brilliant system I've seen. In baseball I like the Red Sox, because I grew up reading about Bill James and sabermetrics, and I find the use of statistics and mathematical analysis to create a winning team really cool. When the Red Sox hired James I predicted that they would immediately start winning big, which they did.
As for basketball, my favorite sport, I'm still a Lakers fan, but that's probably just luck. My two favorite basketball players of all time are Magic and Kobe, and for the last decade or so they have run a difficult, beautiful offense, the triangle. (As I'm writing this, I'm realizing that two of the three teams are in Boston, which is kind of strange. I've been there only once in my life, and it was freezing. I couldn't wait to leave).
What do all these teams have in common? They are fun to watch and they play at an exceptionally high level. I enjoy the characteristics, if not the character, of the people. It's what I want in whatever entertainment I'm taking in, whether movies, music, theater, etc.
Lastly, people need to understand that you don't owe a pro sports team anything. If anything, they owe you since you have given them your money and helped make both the owners and players fabulously wealthy. They don't know you. You don't know them. The players will go from team to team in search of the most money, which is exactly what we would do if we were in their situation. The owners are running a for-profit business; your well-being is only relevant to them as a means to that end.
Have a good night everyone.
JR